Christmas in April

Today, as promised, I’m sharing an excerpt from a new P&P fantasy that I have recently finished writing! At 63 pages, it’s either a very long short story or a short novella, and since it’s presented in a Christmas framework, I will probably wait to publish it until closer to the end of the year. Despite the Christmas framework, though, most of the action actually takes place in April, as you will discover below.

This story is completely unlike anything else I’ve ever written, but then I like new writing challenges! Title? I’m planning on It’s a Wonderful Life, Mr. Darcy, because of the basic premise. Think your life doesn’t matter, Mr. Darcy? Well, here’s what the world would be like if you’d never been born.

I had so much fun puzzling out this fanciful “what if?” And I hope you will enjoy it too. Here’s how the story begins:



Prologue

It is Christmas evening – my first of many happy Christmases with Elizabeth, God willing – and we have dear friends gathered to Pemberley to share it with us. Georgiana is here, of course, and Colonel Fitzwilliam. Mr. Bingley and Jane have come, as well as the entire Gardiner family. I glance at Elizabeth, who sits by my side, her hand tucked in mine. We exchange contented smiles.

It has been a full day. We woke to a blanket of white resting and inch or two thick on the ground – enough to delight everybody but not enough to create much inconvenience. So we were still able to safely reach Kympton to attend divine services on this holy day. Afterward, the Gardiner children played on the lawn, throwing snowballs and building what they could with the limited supply of snow. Some of the adults braved the chilly air again as well, joining in the children’s play or just strolling about in the wintery scene, all of us bundled in boots, layers of clothing, and our warmest coats, hats, and gloves.

Indoors, there have been games and conversation, along with good things to eat morning, noon, and night: hearty but simple fare for the most part, much of it prepared yesterday to lighten the load on the servants today, a few of whom volunteered to remain on duty. But most – anybody with family in the area – have gone off for their own Christmas celebrations.

Now I can see through the drawing room windows that the sky is painted with more pink and orange hues than blues. The day is coming to a close. As I look about myself, at my comfortable home and the happy faces of my dear ones, I know I am the most fortunate of men. So I cannot quite account for what happened last night, the night of Christmas Eve.

Elizabeth lay sleeping peacefully beside me, her warmth merged with my own beneath the covers. By the waning firelight, I could still see the lines of her face and the fall of her dark hair tumbled down across her shoulders. So all was as it should be. But for some reason, I could not rest. Perhaps to remind myself by contrast to be truly grateful for all my blessings, my mind drifted back to a darker period more than eight months ago, to this past April.

Elizabeth had just refuse my first dismal proposal, and I still cannot begin to explain the episode that followed. Was it real or only some kind of an extraordinary dream? I suppose one could rightfully call it a nightmare except for what I learned by it. A painful event, once survived, may be counted a treasure if it proves to have been of tremendous value in the end.

This experience certainly was – a valuable treasure, that is. In truth, it was a great gift, one I shall never forget. Christmas is a time of gift giving, is it not? Perhaps that is why the odd episode came to my mind again last night. But if not a mere dream or even a nightmare, what shall I call it?

It was a visitation.



So there you have it, the first two pages of this long short story! What do you think? Are you intrigued?

“You are too generous to trifle with me. If your feelings are still what they were last April, tell me so at once. My affections and wishes are unchanged, but one word form you will silence me on this subject for ever.” – Pride and Prejudice, chapter 58

Posted in excerpts, Shannon Winslow's writing, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 4 Comments

Spring Update

Spring has officially arrived, and I couldn’t be more delighted! It’s my favorite season. Winter is over, and everything in my garden is coming back to life, including lots of beautiful flowers! Easter will be here in a few days too, and that’s really the inspiration for what I want to share with you today.

In this quiet way, the first fortnight of her visit soon passed away. Easter was approaching, and the week preceding it was to bring and addition to the family at Rosings, which in so small a circle must be important…

Pride and Prejudice, chapter 30

But first, a writing update. It is my stated intention to write another …in His Own Words novel next, this time about Captain Wentworth. And you’ll be pleased to know I have actually begun work on it! I think you’ll enjoy getting to know and understand him better, especially in light of events in his past, which I think may surprise you. I have also finished a draft of a new P&P story (at 63 pages, it’s either a very long short story or a short novella), which I will share an excerpt from next month.

Today, though, I want to feature something else, something timely for this week specifically.

As many of you know, I write an “Inspirational Message” for the local newspaper every other Sunday. It has been a natural outgrowth of the enjoyable challenge I found in writing my Jane Austen devotional Prayer & Praise. Only these messages are even shorter (only about 450 word each), and I can’t lean on Jane Austen’s words to assist me! This is the article that published yesterday. I hope you find it thought provoking.


Skipping to the Happy Ending

When it comes to books and movies, I’m all about the happy ending. Real life doesn’t always deliver, but I figure fiction should. My sister is even more zealous about that policy. You’ve probably seen the wonderful classic movie The Sound of Music, which ends with the whole Von Trapp family escaping the Nazis, over the mountains to freedom and a new life. That’s not good enough for my sister, though. She prefers to stop the video just after the wedding, skipping all the unpleasantness that follows and forgetting the horrid Nazis altogether.

It’s tempting to apply the same philosophy to Holy Week, which starts today with Palm Sunday. How about stopping the movie after Jesus’s triumphal entry into Jerusalem? Quit while everybody’s cheering and Jesus is on top.

When they brought the colt to Jesus… he sat on it. Many people spread their cloaks on the road, while others spread branches… Those who went ahead and those who followed shouted, “Hosanna! Blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord!.. Hosanna in the highest!” (Mark 11:7-10)

That would make a great ending, right? Just stop there and avoid all the unpleasantness that follows. Nobody really wants to see Jesus being arrested, beaten, and crucified after all. Not the crowds who cheered him that first Palm Sunday. Certainly not the disciples who loved and followed him. Not even Satan wanted Jesus crucified! Hmm. Therein lies the problem. More than once, Satan attempted to sidetrack Jesus from His mission (Mt. 4:1-11). He knew that if he could just make Jesus forget about dealing with the ugly sin issue, to skip all the inevitable “unpleasantness” that entailed, he (Satan) would win. As for us? We would all be hopelessly lost, falling into his greedy clutches.

But instead of taking the easy way out, Jesus voluntarily chose to do the hard but necessary thing to save us. He chose to go the way of the cross. That’s why we don’t quit at the partial triumph of Palm Sunday. That’s why we can’t just skip over Jesus’ crucifixion to the greater victory of His resurrection on Easter morning either – at least we ought not. Don’t avert your eyes; face the ugliness of sin and what it cost Jesus. Only then can we rightly appreciate what He achieved for us: the most glorious happy ending ever – eternity in heaven. Because Jesus didn’t skip Good Friday, neither should we.

“If anyone would come after me, he must deny himself, take up his cross, and follow me.” (Mt. 16:24)


Wishing you and your family a meaningful and blessed Holy Week through Easter.

Posted in excerpts, gardening, life, Shannon Winslow's writing, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , | 6 Comments

Reviewing Hallmark’s “Lovuary with Jane Austen”

You would think Hallmark movies were made just for me, since I’m all about romance and happy endings: Hallmark’s stock and trade. So it’s hard to explain why I’m not a big fan. I think it’s the same reason I don’t much care for standard “romance” novels. The formulaic, low-budget, mass-produced nature of both tends to result in less original, lower quality fare. Makes it difficult to sink my whole heart into the story and fall in love.

So I was naturally skeptical when I heard of the Hallmark Channel’s plans for a month-long tribute to Jane Austen, dubbed Loveuary with Jane Austen. I’d been let down before by their attempts at Austen tie-ins, some of which displayed almost no resemblance to an Austen tale beyond the hijacking of her character names. Still, I couldn’t not watch either, not if I wanted to know what everybody would be talking about and contribute an opinion.

For those of you who haven’t followed along, Hallmark has presented a new original movie every Saturday night this month – four in all – all based in some way on Jane Austen and her novels. And they’ve been replaying them and prior films in this category at other times, I understand. I’ve focused only on the four new movies. My overall impressions? I was pleasantly surprised… with two of them. Here’s my breakdown, but I’ll be interested to hear if you agree.


2/3/2024 Paging Mr. Darcy: Specializing in the works of Jane Austen, Dr. Eloise Cavendish is the keynote speaker at this year’s Jane Austen League of America (JALA) conference and ball. But, as an academic through and through, she comes with preconceived ideas and a prejudice against all things frivolous, especially the fact that many attendees seem to be treating the convention like one big Regency costume party. So Eloise is dismayed to be introduced to the convention’s very own “Mr. Darcy,” complete with top hat and cravat. Sam Lee has been hired not only to provide some serious wish-fulfillment for attendees but also as Eloise’ special guest liaison to JALA, throwing them into each other’s constant company. The two get off to a rocky start. But, soon discovering they need each other for their disparate goals, they agree to a truce, which changes them both and leads to a mutual understanding.

What I liked: Will Kemp made an appealing, almost endearing Darcy, showing only the warmer side of the character. And the developing relationship between Sam and Eloise was believable and satisfying, sharing some aspects of the Lizzy/Darcy dynamic, but not forcing it beyond what would be realistic. Having been to 2 JASNA conventions, I also enjoyed seeing some similar elements in the film (although with a lot more silliness for comic effect). This movie doesn’t take itself too seriously, and I appreciate that, for the most part, the filmmakers refrained from throwing in gratuitous JA references that made no sense.

What I didn’t like: The final conflict at the end, which was a little trumped up. Also, the attempt at Regency dancing was completely laughable, when it wouldn’t have been that difficult to get it right.,

Missed opportunity: Were any of you thinking along with me? Toward the end, when Eloise thanks Sam for rescuing her sister (reminiscent of Darcy rescuing Lydia), I thoroughly expected the next words out his mouth would be, “I believe I thought only of you.” Didn’t happen.

Rating: This one pleasantly surprised me, and I would watch it again sometime. 4 stars


2/10/2024 Love & Jane: Lilly Thorpe is in a rut. She works at a job she doesn’t like. She’s become discouraged about ever realizing her dream of becoming a novelist. She’s never gotten around to taking that trip to England. And now she’s turned down the offer from her long-time boyfriend to save her from the doldrums by marrying her and taking her to Chicago. The only thing left that she really enjoys is her role as president of her local Jane Society (as in Jane Austen). Part of what Lilly loves about Jane is that she seems to have an answer for all of life’s problems. So she calls out for help, and surprisingly enough, Jane shows up. Once Jane updates her two-hundred-year-old ideas a bit, she sets out to advise Lilly on her twenty-first-century problems, which now including Trevor Fitzsimmons, the handsome but rude bookstore owner who keeps turning up in Lilly’s life. These two, while on the surface they have much in common, don’t see eye to eye on anything. Can Jane show them the way to love and happiness?

What I liked: The concept is good. Wouldn’t we all love to have Jane Austen pop in to give us wisdom and encouragement along life’s way? To quote a line, “You come when inspiration is needed.” And I liked Kendra Anderson as Jane Austen.

What bugged me: There’s a character in the beginning whose name is Mr. Wickham (or so I thought). I couldn’t understand why he was given that name. For one thing, he’s nothing like the Wickham we know. But more importantly, if his name was really Mr. Wickham, wouldn’t all the members of the Jane Society, who met at his pub, make remarks and jokes about it? – which they did not. Come to find out, the name is really “Whitcomb,” which sounds the same. Again, why do that? There’s also a running gag about Jane advising Lilly that to be a good catch a man should own many head of cattle, as if that were a big thing in Austen’s own life or her novels, which it’s not. Land maybe, money definitely, but not cattle.

Rating: While there were some nice moments, this one fell pretty flat for me – a good concept not developed to its potential. 2 1/2 stars


2/17/2024 An American in Austen: In this one, instead of Jane Austen time travelling to the present day to assist an aspiring novelist, we have the opposite. After giving her boyfriend’s romantic proposal a cringeworthy “maybe,” Harriet Goodson, an aspiring novelist, finds herself unexpectedly transported back to Jane Austen’s day. Not only that, but she’s incorporated into the cast of Pride and Prejudice, her favorite book, where she’s welcomed with open arms by the Bennet family as their eccentric American cousin. At first, Harriet thinks it’s an elaborate gag, but then she has to accept that, somehow, it’s all real. She sets about encouraging the “right” matches, according to how she knows the story is supposed to go. But inevitably her presence and twenty-first century mentality upset the balance. In the process, Harriet discovers it’s not the Regency Mr. Darcy she wants, but the pretty incredible man she left behind in her own time.

What I liked: I enjoyed the modern-girl-transported-to-Regency-England trope, which is not surprising since I wrote one myself (Leap of Hope). This one is reminiscent of Lost in Austen in that the time traveler struggles to keep the P&P story on track while at the same time trying to decide if she loves Mr. Darcy as much as she always thought she would. I got a kick out of the bit with the rooster waking the city girl every morning. And I can’t tell you how surprised I was at the sumptuous settings and locations used (Ireland, Bulgaria). I confess, I had not expected such high-budget realism from Hallmark.

What bugged me: The standard inaccuracies and anachronisms we have come to expect (long hair down, no gloves while dancing, informal address, Bingley in Jane’s bedroom, D&E alone in a carriage). The attempt at Regency dancing was better in this one but not great.

Oddities: 1 – adding a real duchess (Sarah Ferguson) to play a duchess opening the ball. 2 – casting an actress named Eliza Bennett (named so by her parents after P&P‘s Elizabeth Bennet) to star in a P&P-based movie and NOT giving her the role of Elizabeth Bennet.

Rating: I enjoyed it and would watch it again. 4 stars


2/24/2024 Sense and Sensibility: Produced by the Hallmark’s Mahogany division, this movie, as the title implies, is a retelling of Jane Austen’s classic story of the two eldest Dashwood sisters, Elinor and Marianne, finding their different ways along the bumpy path to love. This adaptation retains the period setting and most of the original plot.

What I liked: first, I’m impressed with Hallmark for tackling something this monumental: a remake of a beloved classic novel in a period setting. This is far beyond their usual scope. And using a mixed-race cast was another bold move that adding a new and interesting aspect to this adaptation. Finally (as in An American in Austen), they filmed in impressive settings and locations to sell it. Kudos to them for not trying to get by with less.

What I didn’t like so much: Although I applaud the attempt, this adaptation fell short in several ways, in my opinion. Some really good performances were overshadowed by some really bad acting from other cast members. Screenplay writing choices left me scratching my head – John Dashwood’s awkward apology, and the Dashwood sisters stopping over at Norland (instead of Cleveland) on their travel home from London. The other thing that drew my attention (and not in a good way) was the costuming – not so much the styles but the fabric choices. The bright colors, patterns, and so much shine, instead of looking rich, as I’m sure was intended, seemed out of period. These splashy hats and gowns unfortunately tended to make the actresses wearing them look more clownish than elegant.

Comic Relief: Sir John Middleton had the best lines and made me laugh, especially when he was first introduced. That was a highlight.

Rating: Hallmark bit off more than they could successfully chew with this one. 2 1/2 stars


There you have it, folks. It’s a 50/50 split. Two thumbs up and two thumbs trending down. But that’s just my opinion. Everybody’s tastes are different, so now I want to hear from you.

What are your sentiments about Hallmark movies in general? More particularly, did you watch these 4 Jane Austen tributes? Do you agree or disagree with my evaluations? Which one(s) did you like best or dislike most, and why? A favorite moment / actor /character /event? I’ve talked enough. Now it’s your turn!

Posted in movies, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 13 Comments

Goals: Jane Austen’s and Mine

Do you suppose Jane Austen had specific goals when she started writing as a child? Perhaps not, at least perhaps nothing more than entertaining her family and friends. That’s what she did in her early years. We know that at least by age 12 she was writing poems and short pieces of fiction intended as gifts, not to mention the hundreds, perhaps thousands, of letters she wrote over her lifetime, many of which were highly entertaining too. See one of my favorites here – her backwards letter. (Note: Many of her juvenile works and 160 letters have been preserved and are widely available to read for free.)

But at some point, encouraged by her family and her small successes, Jane must have consciously aspired to becoming a professional, published writer, and she made her first attempts at writing novels (in epistolary form) starting at age 19. The realization of that goal, however, was a long time in coming. Although a publisher bought Susan (what would eventually become Northanger Abbey) in 1803, when Austen would have been 28, he never actually published it! So it wasn’t until some 8 years later (1811), with the publication of Sense and Sensibility, that she finally saw her work in print.

Having at last been published, no doubt JA’s next goal was to earn enough money by her writing to support herself and her household, since the Austen females had been poor for a long time. But then, as her health began to fail her, I can imagine that her sole goal may have been to live long enough to finish her last novel Persuasion. That’s the point of view I took in The Persuasion of Miss Jane Austen, where she tells the story of writing her last and most poignant novel and what inspired it.

I put down my pen that day last August with the gesture of solemn finality appropriate to the occasion. Then I sat a moment, gathering myself for the effort of raising my feeble frame to a standing position, so that I might wind a string round the manuscript I had so lovingly wrought. The Elliots, by A Lady: the title plus my usual epithet written in my own hand on the foremost page.

During the time it took to writ it, my strength had gradually ebbed away to the point where I sometimes wondered if I could go on. Yet there was no turning back. The story consumed me. It dominated my thoughts waking and sleeping. It demanded to be told. So I had obediently forged ahead. That other world, Anne and Captain Wentworth’s, was always with me, its characters and events becoming as real to me as those persons and proceedings belonging to my own household

Like a spider, I had carefully spun the tale’s intricate pattern. And then I neatly knit up all my loose ends, seeing to it that, unlike in real life, everybody not greatly at fault had been returned to tolerable comfort at the last… As author of their lives, if not of my own, I had been able to do that much for them…

I do wonder, though, if it bothered Jane Austen that she started things she wasn’t able to complete: Sanditon and The Watsons fragments. How many other stories did she have in her head that she never had time to write? It’s a good thing she started young, so that she had at least a couple of decades to pursue her writing goals and produce the novels we treasure today.

So are my goals at all similar to Jane Austen’s? I started writing much later in life, but I began, like she probably did, with modest plans. I began writing my first novel, The Darcys of Pemberley, purely for my own entertainment. I wanted more stories like the ones she had written (including a P&P sequel), and I wasn’t finding them. Also, I wanted to see if I could do it! But then, when the book was finished (that goal completed!), I was sufficiently encouraged by the result to seek publication. As for supporting myself by the proceeds of my writing, while it might technically be possible, I’m grateful I don’t have to put that to the test!

Somewhere along the way, though, I did conceive another specific goal related to my writing, and that was to author at least one novel related to each of Austen’s six – something I have now (with the publication of Mr. Knightley in His Own Words last October) at last completed!

  • Pride and Prejudice: The Darcys of Pemberley and four others
  • Sense and Sensibility: Colonel Brandon in His Own Words
  • Northanger Abbey: Murder at Northanger Abbey
  • Emma: Mr. Knightley in His Own Words
  • Persuasion: The Persuasion of Miss Jane Austen
  • Mansfield Park: Leap of Hope

So what’s my next goal? I don’t know if I have or even need one. Everything from here on out is pure gravy! I’ve never aspired to great fame or fortune; I just write what I want I want to write – to challenge and entertain myself – and I’m thrilled that so many others enjoy the books too! That’s enough for me, although… now that I think about it, a movie deal would be nice…



Progress Report: With the goal I mentioned above completed, I’ve been pretty lazy about getting a new project started. But after reader feedback and careful consideration, I’m now planning to write Captain Wentworth in His Own Words next. That, however, will require some research first on mysterious subjects like smuggling and the workings of the Royal Navy during the Regency years. In the meantime, I’ve written about 11K words of what will either be a very long “short story” or a short novella, featuring Mr. Darcy. Since it has a Christmas connection, I will probably release it in November or December. Stay tuned for more info on these projects in the coming months!


PS – Despite the title of this post, Jane Austen never employed the word “goal” in her writing. This I discovered when I went looking for a quote to use. “Aim,” “ambition,” or “aspiration” are about as close as I could come, but by the way they are used, these words often carry a negative connotation, like in this snippet of conversation between Elinor and Edward in Sense and Sensibility. If you were to accuse somebody today of having “no ambition,” they’d probably be offended. Not Edward!

“You have no ambition, I well know. Your wishes are all moderate.” “As moderate as those of the rest of the world, I believe. I wish as well as every body else to be perfectly happy; but, like every body else it must be in my own way. Greatness will not make me so.”

What other goals do you imagine Jane Austen might have had? What about you? What goals did you have when you were young, and have they changed over time?

Posted in Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , | 3 Comments

My Christmas / New Year’s Letter to You

It’s the end of another year – a good time to look back before moving forward. I do that every December, reviewing family events in preparation for writing our traditional Christmas letter/card. Yes, I’m one of the dwindling number who still sends physical Christmas greetings – real paper and envelopes and stamps. I write the letters themselves as much to mark the chapters of our family life as to inform/entertain those who receive them (see Christmas Cards).

“Was his letter a long one? Does he give you much account of what he is doing? Is it Christmas gaieties that he is staying for?”  (Mansfield Park, chapter 29)

I use a single sheet of cardstock, printing the letter on one side with a pretty picture for the cover on the other. Then I fold it in half to make the card. Space is limited! I don’t have that issue here, though. So today, I thought I’d send you all a slightly belated, somewhat expanded version of that Christmas letter, starting with the cover image (a view of Mt. Rainier taken near our house).

I’ve chosen an odd year to do this, I suppose, because I don’t have anything of a glamorous or particularly impressive nature to tell, (not like another author’s year-end wrap up that I just read – travels to Europe, personal appearances, new publishing contract, awards). But maybe this will be more relatable. Anyway, here’s how I began this year’s letter:

Hello, everyone, and Merry Christmas 2023! Another year has flown by, and I’m not sure we have a lot to show for it. We continue much as before, only it seems we spend more time maintaining ourselves, our home, and our vehicles the older we get. In fact, three new maintenance problems have arisen in the last couple of days – two car issues and one appliance!

This is all too true. Our aging fleet of vehicles suffered an abnormal number of problems this year – blown head gaskets, leaking fuel tanks, bad starters, dead batteries, etc. Not one thing at a time either, but multiples, to the point where we thought we might have to borrow back the spare car we had loaned to a friend. And then in the house, it’s been a series of water emergencies (4 at last count) – puddles (leaking refrigerator, leaking dishwasher, leaking hot water tank) to one full-fledged flood (pressure surge bursting connections several places at once)!

So hubby has kept busy this year with car repair projects, major and minor, and both of us with taking apart the kitchen and putting it back together again after our dishwasher leaked, damaging our hardwood floors. Only a small section of the floor actually needed to be replaced, but then ALL of it had to be refinished, which meant removing all the appliances, all baseboard trim, two china cabinets full of breakables, and the dining table and chairs (our living room was piled high for weeks). Lastly we had to move ourselves out to the camp trailer for a few days while the fumes dissipated. What fun!

I did have one positive change to report, though…

The biggest change around the house, though, was actually in the back yard, where we decided to install a large solar panel array. It was a big investment (there went that trip around the world we had planned), but hopefully it will prove to be a smart one.

So no major travels this year, just our annual pilgrimage to Ashley Lake (Kalispell, Montana), joined by my sister and our good friend. A brand new experience awaited us there, though: our first zip line adventure. Since gravity does most of the work, you’re never too old! We all enjoyed it and agreed we’d like to try it again sometime.


Then, of course, I had to brag a little about my kids and grandkids (omitting that part here for their privacy). My other big achievement for 2023 was finishing another novel: Mr. Knightley in His Own Words. Whoohoo! That’s 13 books in the last 13 years. Hope I can keep it up a while longer.

One thing more. I always add an appropriate Bible verse to the top or bottom of the letter – something to remind us of the true meaning of Christmas. Jesus is the reason for the season.

For to us a child is born, to us a son is given, and the government will be on his shoulders. And he will be called Wonderful Counselor, Mighty God, Everlasting Father, the Prince of Peace. – Isaiah 9:6

What will 2024 bring? I don’t know, but I’m praying it will be health, peace, and love for us all.

Do you still send Christmas cards/letters? Have you taken the time to review 2023 in your mind? What was the highlight for you? What are you looking forward to in 2024? Best wishes!

Shannon

Posted in life, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , , | 6 Comments

The Rules of “Movie Day”

Approximately every two weeks, my sister and I declare a “Movie Day!”

We might go to a theatre on the rare occasion there’s actually something of interest to us playing. But usually she comes to my house, arriving mid- to late morning. Which brings me to the first rule of Movie Day. WE ARE NOT REQUIRED TO GET UP EARLY! In fact, we may not actually start our movie(s) before lunch, depending on how late a start we get, how much catching up we need to do first, and how long it takes us to decide what we’re going to watch.

Movie selection is critical, of course. Unless I have a DVD borrowed from the library for us to watch, we normally pick something from my personal collection (which is separate and distinct from my husband’s collection, btw). The question is, what are we in the mood for? Rom-com (i.e. While You Were Sleeping, You’ve Got Mail). Period drama (Jane Austen Adaptations top the list, naturally). Something quirky and fun (like Strictly Ballroom). A musical we can sing along with (The Sound of Music, Mama Mia). It doesn’t matter that we’ve seen some of them a dozen+ times before.

The only overriding principle when choosing is that the MOVIE MUST HAVE A CLASSICLY HAPPY ENDING! This is something my sister is especially adamant about. I can accept an ambiguous ending occasionally, if it’s well done (I Capture the Castle, Before We Go) but she cannot. If in doubt about an intended film, I pre-watch it to be sure it will measure up. That’s part of my job description as movie day hostess.

The other part of our arrangement is that I provide A GORMET LUNCH, INCLUDING DESSERT. She does the driving; I do the cooking. That’s the deal. Quiche is preferred, but panini, tuna/chicken melts, or taco salad are some other acceptable choices.

Since it was my sister’s birthday the last time we had a movie day, I went all out: Quiche Lorraine, served with crisp and juicy grapes on the side, and chocolate cake with Grandma Jensen’s white fluffy frosting. (Not surprisingly, the guest of honor claimed all leftovers as part of her birthday booty to take home for later.) Our movie was also something special: Pride and Prejudice 1980, which she hadn’t seen before. So it was all I could do to prevent myself from constantly adding helpful annotative comments (“That line is taken directly from the book. That one too!”)

Which brings me to our final rule. THE MOVIE IS TOTALLY INTERRUPTABLE, for lunch and dessert, of course, but also for a myriad of other and sundry excuses. We’ll be going along nicely, and then one of us says, “Pause!” Need to check a newly arrived text. Need to ask a question or tell the other person something before we forget. Time for a bathroom break. Or one of us (actually, always my sister) has drifted off to sleep.

This is when the advantage of selecting movies we’ve seen before becomes apparent; full concentration isn’t necessary. Because in the end, despite the name, our “movie days” aren’t primarily about the movies. It’s just a good excuse for us to get together. I guess we should really change the name to “Sister Day!”

Do you have a similar tradition with your sister(s) or best friend? What are your “rules” – the same as ours or different? What’s the last movie you watched with somebody other than your spouse?



A week or ten days rolled quietly away after this visit before any new bustle arose to interrupt even for half a day the tranquil and affectionate intercourse of the two sisters, whose mutual regard was increasing with the intimate knowledge of each other which such intercourse produced. (The Watsons)

Posted in movies, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , | 2 Comments

That’s a Wrap, So What’s Next?

Inevitably, when all the excitement of releasing a new book is over, the question arises, “What should I write next?” That’s where I am now.

Mr. Knightley in His Own Words is successfully launched and the blog tour completed. (If you missed any of it, see links in previous post.) The book is receiving really good reviews too! – with a 4.7 star average at Amazon and 4.58 stars at Goodreads. So I’m happy about that. Here are a couple of the best comments so far:

I loved this book…You did something I did not think was possible. You made me like the Emma-Knightley love story. I never cared for Emma; it was my least-liked Austen book. But you fixed it! (beta reader comment)

I have LOVED LOVED LOVED all of this author’s “in his own words” books. This might be the best of the lot! (Amazon customer review)

Hopefully word-of-mouth will do the rest, leaving me free to move on to a new project (although I admit it will be difficult to say good-bye to Mr. Knightley!). But what shall I write next? I have ideas, of course, but I always like to ask for reader input as well! So here are some suggestions for your consideration:

  1. another …in His Own Words book, possibly starring Persuasion‘s Captain Wentworth this time
  2. a P&P/Romeo and Juliet mash-up (probably novella length) – proposed title: Darcio and Lizziet
  3. a P&P prequel novel about the courtships of the Bennets and the Gardiners
  4. something else altogether! What’s your idea?

Although I have played around with these (and even written a bit of #2 & 3), I haven’t committed to anything yet. So I really am open to suggestions at this time. Please leave me a comment, letting me know what you’d like me to write! Or something about Mr. Knightley in His Own Words. Have you read it yet? It’s now available in audio! – as well as Kindle, paperback, and Nook.

In the meantime, though, I thought I might as well share this brief, potential prologue for the Bennet/Gardiner novel, which I wrote quite a while ago. I hope you find it entertaining!



Kneeling before a woman, even a decidedly pretty one, is a damned uncomfortable position to find one’s self in. That was the undeniable fact of the matter. Not that Thomas Montgomery Bennet had any doubt of his reception being favorable. One’s proposal of marriage was generally accepted, he understood, and, judging from the eager look in Miss Fanny Gardiner’s eye, this would be no exceptional case. Still, someone might have warned him.

This was only one of the myriad of thoughts coursing through young Mr. Bennet’s brain at that critical moment, for his mind was quick enough to encompass a good deal at once, when he took the trouble of exerting himself. And what occasion could possibly justify – no, demand – his absolute attention more than this one, on which so much depended?

So now, when he perhaps ought to have been, to the exclusion of all else, anticipating his joy at soon being accepted, he was also anticipating his simultaneous relief at being allowed to return to a more upright, dignified posture. When he ought to have been fully engaged in celebrating Miss Gardiner’s considerable beauty and charming amiability – soon to be his and his alone in marriage – different, rather distracting ideas intruded.

“She has no money to speak of,” his friend Edward, the fair Miss Gardiner’s elder brother, had told him plainly enough. And his own father’s advice on the subject had carried an even stronger word of caution. “God willing, you will be married a very long time. Therefore, take care you do not choose your partner in life unwisely.”

Is that what he had done? Well, if so, it was clearly too late to reconsider; the question had been asked and now answered. Fanny had wasted no time in saying yes before launching into long, rather noisy effusions of delight.

For better or for worse, young Mr. Bennet’s fate was sealed. Meanwhile, Edward Gardiner’s future remained uncertain, his lady love’s heart as yet unplighted. Who was to say which one would be happier in the end?



Mr. Bennet was so odd a mixture of quick parts, sarcastic humour, reserve, and caprice, that the experience of three and twenty years had been insufficient to make his wife understand his character. Her mind was less difficult to develope.

Pride and Prejudice, chapter 1
Posted in audio books, blog hop, excerpts, my books, Shannon Winslow's writing, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , , | 12 Comments

“Mr. Knightley in His Own Words” – It’s Here!

Have you ever participated in a “progressive dinner”? It was a fun, social thing they did back in the day – church groups, etc.. You all ate the appetizer at one person’s house. Then you moved on as a group to somebody else’s for the salad, then the main course at a third place, and dessert at a fourth – progressing from house to house. That’s what I’ve got planned for you today to celebrate the launch of Mr. Knightley in His Own Words!

You start by going to Austen Variations for the appetizer (the book blurb and Prologue) – just enough to  whet your appetite. Then you’ll be moving on to The Calico Critic to read the first half of chapter 1. Think of it as a flavorful salad – tasty, but not quite enough to completely satisfy your hunger. And so you’ll find the second half of the chapter (the main course?) right back here! I promise you will discover some tasty bits to surprise your palate as you go!

Of course, you’re welcome at any time along the way to cut to the chase – skip directly to dessert! Simply go get your own copy now ( Amazon for Kindle and paperback, and audio, B&N for Nook) to  enjoy in the comfort of your own home. Devour it slowly, one bite at a time, or binge to your heart’s content!

I’m delighted to bring Mr. Knightley’s full savory story to you, and I hope you’ll enjoy getting to know our deliciously handsome hero much better. One ARC reader said this is my best “in His Own Words” book of all!  So off you go now, and I’ll meet you back here in a bit for the main course (below).



Coming away to town has not made my mind any easier, though. I have the strong sense that we are at a critical juncture, and no one but myself seems to be aware of the danger. Little does poor Mr. Woodhouse suspect that Frank Churchill is about to cut up his happiness and destroy his peace of mind forever. As for Emma, I fear she is about to make the biggest mistake of her life. My own painful situation aside, I must think and do what is best for them; this I have resolved. And yet, what can I do? I have been over it time and again and see no useful measures to be taken. Emma will not heed my warnings. Neither will her father. And so my comprehending the imminent danger avails nothing at all.

Having concluded that there is no relieving action I can take myself, I have no choice but to await the outcome of events that are in other hands. Meanwhile, here in Brunswick Square, I intend to distract myself as well as possible.

John and Isabella’s children will serve as an excellent diversion, if I will allow them to be. And to the extent I can give them pleasure, my time here will not be wasted. My other strategy is to set down a record of the past. Perhaps these ramblings of mine will be fit only for the fire in the end, but while I confine my thoughts to the past, I may at least forget my current trouble for a little.

I suppose I should start this narration at the beginning; that would make the most sense. I must go back to the events that established the rule for all the rest: why it is that I owe Mr. Woodhouse my complete loyalty, and why our two families are forever bound together – not only now by John and Isabella’s marriage, but many years prior to that. I must start in 1791, the year before Emma was born.

Until that time, nothing extraordinary had occurred to me. Life was quiet, pleasant, and good. Both my parents lived, and my brothers and I went on well together, making all Highbury – Hartfield and Donwell Abbey in particular – our personal grounds for play and exploration. I say “my brothers,” because there were three of us then, you see. I was in the middle at the age of fifteen, with John four and a half years my junior and poor Miles less than two years my senior.

But then my uncle Spencer Knightley came to stay.

I must have intuitively understood the event’s significance even at the time, for I remember with preternatural clarity the conversation between my parents that heralded my uncle’s arrival. It was a quiet evening at Michaelmas, and we were all gathered in the drawing room. John sat on the floor playing with his collection of toy soldiers, and the rest of us divided our time between conversation and reading – Miles and I with books, my father with his paper, and my mother reading the letters that had arrived earlier.

Mama’s little gasp of surprise suddenly drew my attention. “Your brother is coming!” she told her husband with a certain tone of wariness that seemed to always be employed when speaking of my uncle.

“Spencer?” asked Papa, looking up from his paper with a scowl. “I wonder what he can possibly want here at this time of year.”

“Heaven only knows. He just says that we are to expect him tomorrow. Gracious!”

“Steady, Margaret. Now then, let me have a look,” he said, reaching across to receive the letter from my mother’s extended hand.

Mama said no more; she quietly waited for my father’s opinion, as she always did. She had a very good mind of her own, but a natural timidity of spirit and diffidence as to her rightful claims had given her the habit of always deferring to others, especially her husband, on serious matters. His good judgement and benevolence made this practice no bad thing, while he lived.

She sat poised on the edge of her chair, the perfect picture of the refined lady. She was a bit taller than average with a figure only mildly the worse off for the three sons she had borne. Her hair was still a fine shade of auburn, I remember, although laced with a little silver filigree by that time. She seemed to me somewhat advanced in years, although I suppose she was no more than five years older than I am now, and still a very handsome woman.

After briefly scanning the single-paged letter for himself, my father said, “Spencer can mean nothing serious by this – only a short visit. After all, he must be back in town for the beginning of next term, you know.”

“Yes, of course. Well, I suppose we can put up with him for a few days, can’t we?” Although she sounded none too sure.

“We can and we must. He is my own twin, after all, and this is his home too, in one sense of the word. I can hardly turn him away at the door.”

“No. No, of course not.”

My father, who was ten years older than my mother and fully gray by this time, tossed the letter aside, tended his pipe, and returned to his paper. Mama kept silent for a few minutes, as if she agreed the matter was settled and meant to say no more about it. And yet, from the corner of my eye I observed her restless fidgets. Finally she seemed not to be able to stifle her disquietude in any longer.

“It is just that…”

“Yes, my dear?” said my father, looking over the top of his spectacles at her.

“It is just that with Spencer’s history… Your history with him, that is… His implacable resentment. Well, I do not like his coming unexpectedly like this. Uninvited too. I cannot help thinking it does not bode well. No, it does not bode well at all, and I shall be uneasy until he has been and gone again.”

My father frowned and gave his wife a significant look accompanied by a slight tilt of his head in my direction, which put an end to the discussion of Uncle Spencer, at least within my hearing, and left me to wonder what it all meant. To what “history” did my mother refer? And why was she so uneasy about my uncle’s coming?

Later that night, I decided to talk it over with my brother Miles in private. We were quite close – in age and even more so in temperament – and we had always shared a bedchamber by choice. Oh, how I miss him, even now! He was my best friend as well as an excellent brother, always there by my side to defend and guide me. So naturally I wanted to hear his opinion on the business with our uncle. He had nearly two years more life experience, if nothing else, but I also thought it possible my father had confided more to him, since he was the heir.

“Say, Miles, what do you know about this business with Uncle Spencer?” I asked after we had retired for the night. I had lain awake in the dark, thinking, and was quite sure by the sound of his breathing that he was still awake as well.

His instant answer confirmed it. “What do you mean?”

“The mysterious ‘history’ with our father that Mama spoke of, and why is she so nervous about his coming?”

“Oh, that. Well I know very little – probably no more than you do – but I have always supposed there to be some bad blood between them because of Father’s inheriting and Spencer’s not.”

I considered this. “But why should Uncle resent Father for that? It is not his fault. I do not resent you because I was born second.”

“That is because you have a nobler spirit, George. You always have had. Honestly, though, it does not seem fair, does it? – that I should get it all, and you and John practically nothing, just because of an accident of birth?”

“Not when you put it like that. But then, I have never considered it an accident. It is all part of God’s plan somehow. Is not that right? I am sure I have heard the vicar preach on that subject before.”

“Yes, and I do hope so – that it is God’s plan, and that I will prove worthy of the responsibility when it comes my time. Still, think of Uncle Spencer. If younger sons resent not inheriting, as I believe they often do, think what Uncle must feel as the younger twin. He missed his chance by only a few minutes, not years. It must make the bitter pill even more difficult to swallow. Do not you think so? Like a cruel trick of fate.”

“Miles?” I said after a little silence.

“Yes, George?”

“You do not suppose Uncle means to make any trouble over it, do you?”

“No. I cannot imagine how he could, even if he wished to. Donwell belongs to Father, all legal, right, and tight. Nothing can change that.”

“And after father, it will be yours, not Uncle’s. Is that not so?”

“Exactly so. And I will always look after Mother and you and John. You can rest easy on that head.”

I lay awake a while longer considering all this. Miles had explained the probable source of the conflict so well that I thought I could understand. He was correct, too, as I would later learn, although there was more to it than that. Uncle Spencer came the following day, and so began a very dark period of our lives.



Congratulations! You’ve finished your progressive feast for today! All except dessert: the rest of the story. Did you learn some surprising new things about Mr. Knightley already? I promise there’s a lot more to come. UPDATE: If you’re still undecided, you can now continue reading into chapter 2 at Austenprose: The Trouble with Uncle.

Next, Mr. Knightley in His Own Words goes on a low-key tour (by which I mean no hoopla, outrageous promotions, or giveaways). The goal is just to get the word out about the book. So follow along for fun (live links below as they become available). But if you’d like to know what kind of trouble Uncle Spencer creates, what heroics Mr. Woodhouse performs, and the secrets of George Knightley’s love life, as well as all the rest, don’t wait! Get a copy of the full book for yourself at Amazon or B&N.

Posted in Austen Variations, book launch, excerpts, my books, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , | Leave a comment

Preview Post for “Mr. Knightley in His Own Words”

It’s coming soon! Mr. Knightley in His Own Words will launch in exactly two weeks, on October 5th! The paperback and Kindle versions should both be available on that date (preorder your Kindle copy here), and I’m excited to tell you that the audiobook is already in production too. So it shouldn’t lag very far behind.

I revealed the Kindle cover over at Austen Variations about three weeks ago, but I always like to hold something back especially for the readers of my own blog. So without further ado, here for the first time anywhere is the full paperback cover!

I’m delighted with the way it turned out, and I hope you like it too! (Click on picture to enlarge.)

As you probably know, I asked for and took into account a lot of reader feedback in developing the cover design – specifically which Mr. Knightley to feature (see The Mr. Knightley Pageant post here, and Cover Prototypes at Austen Variations). But did you know that I received and considered reader feedback for the story line too? I asked what else people wanted to know about Mr. Knightley (since Jane Austen tells us so little), what they thought might have happened in his past. And then I took notes!

I couldn’t use them all, unfortunately, but here are some of the great ideas I collected from you, which did end up in the book in one form or another: heart broken by a gorgeous social climber, wicked uncle scheming to get his hands on Donwell, boyish crush on Mrs. Woodhouse, gratitude for some past service by Mr. Woodhouse, Mrs. Woodhouse taking a motherly role for him, show previous links between the Woodhouses and Knightelys, he lives alone after suffering many losses, a London “season,” ignores/suppresses his growing feelings for Emma.

My thoughts had been running along the same lines as many of yours, and I think you’ll find a few other things not mentioned here that I cooked up on my own. In any case, I loved hearing your ideas! Brainstorming like that really gets the creative juices flowing!

As always, I’ve started with the facts of Austen’s original novel and added on (not varied from them). In this case, I’ve added on in the dimension of time. In fact this book is 2/3 prequel! It breaks down into thirds – three key time periods: Mr. Knightley as a youth (age 15-16), as a young man (age 23), and his present day age (the period covered in the original novel Emma), all told in his own words. Learn the events that still haunt him and yet have shaped who he’s become, the superior man Emma can’t help falling in love with.

I hope you’ll join me in welcoming this, my 12th novel, Mr. Knightley in His Own Words, out into the world on October 5th! (Remember, you can preorder your Kindle copy now here)


“Mr. Knightley’s air is so remarkably good, that it is not fair to compare Mr. Martin with him. You might not see one in a hundred, with gentleman so plainly written as in Mr. Knightley.” – Emma Woodhouse, Emma

Posted in my books, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , | 9 Comments

North and South: a Review

I know you were probably expecting the COVER REVEAL for Mr. Knightley in His Own Words, and that IS COMING SOON! I promise. I have it planned for next week, Aug. 28th, at Austen Variations (see it now!), so I’m really hoping my graphic designer and I will finish our work in time! Fingers crossed. In the meantime, catch up by reading previous posts and the book’s page.

I have something else for you today – a review of North and South – mostly the film adaptation but with some comments on Elizabeth Gaskell’s classic novel too. Have you read it?

I first read the novel back in 2007 during my desperate quest to find more books like Jane Austen wrote, and before I started writing my own. I honestly don’t remember much of my impressions of the book at the time. It wasn’t Jane Austen, but I liked N&S well enough to follow it with another Gaskell classic: Wives and Daughters. Then at some point, I discovered the 2004 mini-series, starring Richard Armitage and Daniela Denby-Ashe, which I immediately purchased for my permanent collection.

After re-watching it with my sister recently on one of our “movie days,” I decided that I should read the book again (which I did in audio, with the talented Juliet Stevenson as narrator). So both book and film adaptation are now fresh in my mind!

First, a few words about the book. Set in Victorian England, North and South tells the story of Margaret Hale, a refined clergyman’s daughter from the rural south, who is uprooted to the industrial north, where she meets the not-quite-a-gentleman Mr. Thornton, cotton mill owner. There’s a definite Pride and Prejudice vibe in that the two principals come from different worlds and don’t get along at all in the beginning. The Thorntons think Margaret gives herself undeserved airs of superiority. Meanwhile, Margaret is put off by the northerners’ rough ways, saving her greatest contempt for Mr. Thornton. As you might expect, though, they gradually learn to better understand each other over the course of the book.

While not at all similar in style to Jane Austen’s, Elizabeth Gaskell’s prose is quite lovely to read/listen to, and I thoroughly enjoyed the book on this second visit. It’s quite long, however (around 500pgs) – a plus in some minds but not necessarily in mine. In my opinion, it could be substantially abridged (and no doubt has been by somebody) without losing the life and nuance of the story.

As longwinded as Gaskell seems at times, however, she certainly didn’t waste any extra words on the last chapter. (Warning. There is technically a spoiler ahead. Although, come on; you know the guy and the girl are going to get together in the end, right?). As I saw the “minutes remaining” dwindle down on my audiobook, I actually wondered if there was time enough left to get to the happy ending – Margaret reaching her good understanding with Mr. Thornton at last! We did get there, and it was deliciously sweet, but then it was over all too soon.

The only other caution is to be prepared for a high body count. I’m not naming names, but a lot of people die in this book (primarily by natural causes, not violence). So don’t get too attached to the secondary characters!

Now, on to the film adaptation. I love that the filmmakers used the mini-series (4 hours) format to tell this complex story, rather than trying to do it justice in under 2 hours! I also love that the adaptation remains very true to the original novel in essentials. And my re-read reminded me how much of the movie’s dialogue came straight from Elizabeth Gaskell. Good on them for not feeling the need to “improve” on what was pretty great to begin with. The cast is top notch too, with Sinead Cusack, Brendan Coyle, and Anna Maxwell Martin playing pivotal roles (added to the leads, Armitage and Denby-Ashe).

With the medium of film, we naturally lose the internal dialogue of the characters (Note: the book is written in the omniscient voice, and we hear the thoughts and feelings of both primary characters as well as occasionally a secondary). But we also gain something with film: all the wonderful visuals contrasting the verdure Margaret has come from with the smoky gray of where she now finds herself. Filming took place in Edinburgh, Selkirk, Keighley, and even inside a fully operational vintage cotton mill museum in Burnley.

The film adaptation does stray from the book in a few places. Margaret venturing into the mill was a nice addition. Along with her, we get a good look at the strange and foreign place where Mr. Thornton reigns as “master.” I’m not quite sure fabricating a trip for Margaret to the Great Exhibition in London was necessary. It’s not in the book, but it does no harm and is an interesting historical touch. And I won’t even quibble with the choice to set the final scene in the railway station instead of the privacy of a drawing room. Admittedly, it’s not period correct at all (having them kissing in public), but it certainly adds some very satisfying visuals necessarily lacking in the corresponding scene of the book, which is so abbreviated. In fact, I always back it up to watch the scene multiple times before finally allowing the film to end.

There’s only one scene in the whole film to which I take exception – great exception! That is the scene where Margaret first encounters Mr. Thornton, which in the adaptation occurs at his mill. Thornton catches a worker smoking on the job (a serious offense and a genuine danger in such a combustible environment), and he proceeds to administer discipline with his fists and his feet. Let me emphasize, THIS NEVER HAPPENS IN THE BOOK! I think it was the filmmakers shortcut to explain why Margaret despises Mr. Thornton from the outset (rather than doing the hard work of showing that her prejudice is based on something more subtle: cultural differences). It works; she despises him all right! But how could she ever love and trust him later? Cultural differences can be overcome with mutual understanding; a propensity to violence cannot.

So although I love this mini-series and have watched it at least a dozen times, I always have to give this disclaimer whenever I recommend it. “It’s great, except for this one scene…” Darn! If only they had consulted me first, I could have spared the filmmakers committing this serious error. Then I could have given North and South a full 5-star recommendation instead of 4 and a half!

Have you seen it? Read the book? What is your assessment of each?


“South or north, I know a black cloud when I see it; and you must not set forward while it is so threatening…”

Jane Austen, Mansfield Park, chapter 22

Interested in my other movie reviews? Here they are: Amazing Grace: a Must See Movie. Zombie Date Night: Pride & Prejudice & Zombies. A Tale of Two Movies: Far From the Madding Crowd / Unleashing Mr. Darcy. Becoming a Fan of Becoming Jane. Lady Susan: the most unlikely heroine (Love and Friendship). A Movie Review: Emma 2020. And a related post: My Movie Picks.

Posted in audio books, Austen Variations, England, movies, Uncategorized | Tagged , , , , , , , | 6 Comments